Confessor 20th century

Saint Alexis Toth Confessor and Defender of Orthodoxy in America

1853 – 1909

Also known as Alexis of Wilkes-Barre · Alexis Toth

A Carpatho-Russian priest in North America who, meeting hostility as an Eastern-rite Catholic, returned with many of his people to the Orthodox Church, becoming the great gatherer of Slavic immigrants into Orthodoxy in America; he reposed in 1909.

Feast Day
May 7
Draft
Draft — pending review. Not yet verified for publication.
Commemorated as

Saint Alexis Toth, Confessor and Defender of Orthodoxy in America

Come to them for
Missionary Work

Life

Alexis Georgievich Toth was a Carpatho-Russian priest whose return to the Orthodox Church set in motion one of the largest movements of Eastern-rite Catholics into Orthodoxy in North America. Born in 1853 in the Austrian Empire among the Rusyn people of the Carpathian region, he came to the United States in 1889 as a Greek Catholic (Uniate) pastor and, after being refused by the local Latin hierarchy, led his Minneapolis parish and ultimately many thousands of his countrymen back to the Orthodox faith of their ancestors. He is commemorated on May 7, the day of his repose, and is also known as Saint Alexis of Wilkes-Barre.

Toth was born on March 14, 1853, in the village of Kobylnice near Presov (Eperjes), in what is today eastern Slovakia. He studied at a Latin Catholic seminary, a Greek Catholic seminary, and theology at the university in Prague. He married in 1878 and was ordained a Greek Catholic priest the same year, but his wife and child died soon after, leaving him a widower. Before his emigration he served in parishes and held positions as a diocesan chancellor and as a teacher and administrator at the Greek Catholic seminary in Presov.

Sent to minister to Rusyn immigrants, Toth arrived in the United States on November 15, 1889, and within weeks was serving St. Mary's Greek Catholic parish in Minneapolis. When he presented himself to Archbishop John Ireland of St. Paul and Minneapolis, he was rejected: Ireland did not regard Toth or his Eastern bishop as truly Catholic and forbade him to function as a priest in the city. This rebuff, together with longstanding tension over the standing of Eastern-rite Catholics in America, led Toth and his parish to seek union with the Russian Orthodox Church. He was received into Orthodoxy through the ministry of Bishop Vladimir (Sokolovsky), and over the following years he became the foremost gatherer of Slavic immigrants into the Orthodox Church, by tradition bringing more than twenty thousand Carpatho-Russian and Galician Uniates into Orthodoxy.

Toth was elevated to the rank of protopresbyter and continued his missionary labors among immigrant communities, including service at Holy Trinity Cathedral in Chicago and in the coal-mining parishes of Pennsylvania. He reposed on May 7, 1909, in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, and was buried at St. Tikhon's Monastery in South Canaan, Pennsylvania. He was glorified as a saint by the Orthodox Church in America on May 29, 1994, and is venerated as a confessor and defender of Orthodoxy in America.

Timeline 7 moments Read Hide
  1. 1853 Birth Born March 14 in Kobylnice near Presov, in the Austrian Empire (today eastern Slovakia).
  2. 1878 Marriage and ordination Married and ordained a Greek Catholic priest; his wife and child died soon after.
  3. 1889 Arrival in America Arrived in the United States on November 15 and began serving St. Mary's parish in Minneapolis.
  4. 1889 Rejected by Archbishop Ireland Archbishop John Ireland refused to recognize Toth and forbade him to serve as a priest in the city.
  5. 1891–1892 Return to Orthodoxy Toth and St. Mary's parish were received into the Russian Orthodox Church through Bishop Vladimir (Sokolovsky).
  6. 1909 Repose Reposed on May 7 in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania; buried at St. Tikhon's Monastery.
  7. 1994 Glorification Glorified as a saint by the Orthodox Church in America on May 29.

Contributions & Legacy

2 contributions Read Hide

Conflict in Minneapolis

Eastern-rite Catholic clergy in late nineteenth-century America occupied an uncertain place: their married priesthood and distinct liturgical tradition were viewed with suspicion by the Latin hierarchy. When Toth, a widowed Greek Catholic priest, made the customary call upon the local Latin bishop, Archbishop John Ireland, he was met with anger rather than welcome. By Toth's own account Ireland threw his priestly credentials onto the table and protested his presence in the city, declaring that he did not consider Toth or his bishop to be genuinely Catholic and refusing him faculties to serve in Minneapolis.

Sources differ on the precise sequence and dating of the return that followed. According to one account the parish, finding itself without recognized standing, contacted the Russian consul in San Francisco in December 1890 to be put in touch with a Russian Orthodox bishop, and Toth formally entered the Russian Orthodox Church in March 1892 together with 361 of his people. Other accounts place his reception by Bishop Vladimir (Sokolovsky) in February 1891, with the parish formally accepted in March 1892. In either telling, St. Mary's of Minneapolis became the first of the immigrant Uniate parishes to return to Orthodoxy under his leadership.

Mission to the Immigrants

Toth's reception of St. Mary's was the beginning of a much wider movement. He traveled among the Carpatho-Russian and Galician immigrant settlements scattered through the industrial towns and coal regions of the northeastern United States, preaching, instructing, and gathering parishes that had come as Uniates into communion with the Orthodox Church. The tradition credits his labors with the return of more than twenty thousand Eastern-rite Catholics to Orthodoxy.

His work unfolded alongside that of the other builders of Orthodox life in America in this period, and the diocese he served would later be led by Saint Tikhon, the future Patriarch of Moscow. Toth was honored with elevation to protopresbyter and continued his missionary service until his death.

Notes

Region of origin (Carpatho-Rus'/Slovakia) has no controlled term; left blank. Modern North American saint.

Sources: OCA Synaxarion (oca.org), Lives of the Saints